HERE WE GO AGAIN, Mother Nature in Charge Nelson hydro customers Shafted

Mother Nature's Cycle Repeats
and your electric bill pays for a project, the result of a
phony engineers report showing a business case for the
Community Solar Garden



             Above is a typical year of Kootenay Lake level, spring runoff has begun once again.

Spring runoff refills Kootenay Lake, Duncan Lake and Lake Koocanusa (Libby Dam) storing over 6 million acre feet of water our winter batteries.  Power for millions of homes that all begins to draw down as shown above at the beginning of the year.

Spring runoff has begun, reservoirs are filling, dams overflowing, floods occurring, the sun has finally come out and begun to make solar power we don't need it now we can't even use all the water,  solar power that has the same value as the water spilling  $$ZERO$$.  $0.  Nada., nothing. Zip! 

In winter when we could use the solar power the solar garden made enough power for little more than one house. $400,000, payments of $24,000/yr for 25 years the life expectancy of solar panels and then they become toxic waste.

Nelson hydro can make that year of solar power for about $500 and sell for a 1400% profit.

Payments continue even when summer solar power has no value.


How did the Nelson hydro manager present a business case to city council for the solar garden?

How about asking him to show you. (UPDATE OCT 2020 the Hydro manager left)

I have, no comment.  I have asked mayor and council no comments.

He said it aligned with the city Path to 2040 all about GHG reduction, I have asked him how, he won't comment.

His contractor was on the radio saying community solar power would reach grid parity in 7 years, I asked him for the calculations, he won't comment.

The contractor and other media articles attributed to him said it would pay back in 10 or 12 years, I ask him to show me the calculations, he won't comment.

I ask why Nelson hydro pays full retail for Solar garden power, the Balfour public buildings solar power systems installed with public grant money a private microhydro producer and any others when the bylaw says they won't buy any power unless it makes economic sense for Nelson hydro?
No answer, city council won't answer.  No one will comment.

BullFrog Power contributed money, they sell this as green power to anyone dumb enough to
buy in, the City of Toronto one year bought in, when they figured it out, a reporter asked the
city manager will they renew the contract next year, he replied "it won't see the light of day"

The Solar garden was a political stunt, it was supposed to be voluntary and fully funded by anyone
opting in, that didn't happen, you and I pay with our hydro bills and will as long as it lasts
if it makes its 25 year life expectancy.

The project was dishonest and unethical from the outset.  In two consecutive yearly rate applications to the BCUC by Nelson hydro the manager stated the solar garden was FULLY funded by those opting in.  I have repeatedly asked him what FULLY funded means, because you and I pay, he won't respond.  Now the city uses the term Largely funded.  They try to spin it, reinvent it, but the lies can't be reinvented or changed.



Penticton looked at solar, they state on their  city web site solar would have to be subsidized over 50%.  Anyone familiar with BC knows Penticton gets more sun than Nelson, they grow peaches.

Kelowna planned a similar system the Utilities Commission denied it saying it was of no benefit to anyone even though those opting in would pay a premium for the solar power. 



The hydro manager and his consultant brought the city council what they wanted, a business case
for the solar garden even though there could never be one, did they think no one would ever know?
Professionals disrespecting their professional ethics, 
Disrepecting the public taxpayer and Nelson hydro customers left paying for this and the
remaining years left of the 25 year contracts.
I complained to the Association of Professional Engineers of BC they did nothing.

I have complained 
Past and present mayors and council have all the information

ACCOUNTABILITY ---- NONE

Update  Oct. 2020 the hydro manager left, unaccountable.  The city still won't tell the truth.
And all Nelson hydro customers are left paying for this scam.  Paying full retail for this feel good
solar power so that money can be distributed to the church groups co-ops and others who thought they were helping to save the planet buying a 25 year contract for the power of a solar panel. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Nelson Bike Route Grant Application FRAUD?

Image
In My opinion this grant application is designed to extract the maximum amount available, from the  $500,000 available, why didn't they go for the full amount? What number is correct, or is it all a guess? The first newspaper story shows $670,000 with $180,000 from the city. I have seen $650,000, the application I have shows $608,000.  At the public meeting the city planner upon my questioning about costs stated there was a 40% contingency built in. The grant suggests 20% contingency maximum, so why is he telling me 40%?                               UPDATE:   City council meeting June 2  High St. one way is not going ahead to be reviewed at a future date. A major part of the application costs, is the application amount adjusted? I have asked the city councilor on the project if there are any quotes supporting their costs. For example over $37,000 for signage and painti...
Read more

UNDERSTANDING THE VALUE OF SOLAR IN THE WEST KOOTENAYS

Image
  UPDATE FEBRUARY 2022 FINALLY SOME HONESTY   Solar garden costs 47c/kWh, and they said it would reach parity in 7 years.  Nelson hydro wholesale cost of power generation about 2c/kWh,  Solar is about 25 times more, PARITY??????? Below quoted from the city website  Utility companies use Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE) as a metric for investment planning. It establishes a common comparative baseline across various forms of discounted energy generation over their lifetime. An updated  project analysis  completed in February 2022 concluded that 248 panels were installed from November 2015 to June 2017 at an actual cost of $331,372 generating an average of 66,622 kWh annually, with a customer investment of $221,657.30. Calculating the LCOE from an investment perspective using the project and maintenance actuals to the end of 2021 results in an LCOE of $0.47/kWh.   At least 25 X  more than Nelson hydro's wholesale cost of power! And it a...
Read more

The Real Engineering Report on the Economics of Solar in BC

Image
This article is not about solar but more about professional ethics, dishonesty, public deception and accountability........there is NONE> I complained to the Professional engineers Society of BC, mayor council and many others.  So far, any eco website or green related media block, deny, and disallow my comments and information, they have an agenda, its not about public money and economics.  As long as this continues our public pockets will continue to be picked for this waste of public dollars. Update 9/2020  The Nelson hydro manager, engineer who brought a  phony engineering report to city council showing them the Community Solar Garden  had a business case has left,  unaccountable  for his dishonesty and disrespect to his professonal ethics, his mayor and council, the city taxpayers and Nelson hydro ratepayers.  This leaves the CAO and others still accountable for all the dishonesty.  I provided all the information to the previous mayor...
Read more